The size and shape makes this similar to one of Lovey’s all-time favorite toys (the catnip banana), so it wasn’t surprising that she took to it immediately. Toys like this are sometimes called “kickers” because cats will hold them in their front paws and then kick at them with their feet. It’s actually very adorable to watch and, I imagine, fun for kitty to do. Like Lovey’s beloved banana, this is also stuffed with catnip, so she was quickly drawn in, and it even comes with a spare satchel of catnip to sprinkle on top. The bone-shaped (and bone-colored) toy is made from natural linen that, so far, seems pretty tough. I’ve seen my cat rip open other catnip toys in just one or two play sessions, so it’s nice to see that this one still looks brand new after being kicked, bitten, and clawed at.

While most of the stuff you’ll find at Tuft & Paw is neutral-hued, here’s something a little more vivid. Designed to look just like a salmon tail, this toy isn’t quite as on-brand as the rest of the earth-toned selection, but it sort of reminds me of an Areaware food puzzle in how it’s photo-realistic in a cool way. Like the Fish Bone, it’s a good size and shape for cats to play with, and filled with catnip. Needless to say, Lovey pounced on it without any encouragement from me, and it’s made of a thick (but soft) cotton that’s been holding up well so far.

I have to admit that I like this teepee more than Lovey does. She’s definitely more of a climbing cat who enjoys perching up high and watching the world below her, so I suspected she wouldn’t be into cuddling in this small space. It’s a very nice product, though, with a sturdy wood base and a canvas cover that’s secured with a series of snaps and rubber bands to withstand rowdy cats. It comes with Ikea-style (diagrams; no words) instructions and I was able to assemble it on my own in about ten minutes.

While Lovey hasn’t expressed much interest in the tent yet, I haven’t given up on her. It comes with a fluffy cushion to line the base, and I suspect that might make her feel a little cramped inside, so I’m planning on replacing the cushion with a flatter pillow or just a soft T-shirt. I am committed to getting her to like it because I really want to keep the tent in the living room. It’s just that cute. If you know your cat is the type to enjoy an enclosed house, it’s worth the investment for an actually attractive object that’ll give her a place to get cozy. Otherwise, I’d go for one of the perches or trees.

I don’t have the space or money for another fancy cat tree, but if I did, I would consider splurging on this very impressive one. I can see Lovey scampering up the ramp to reach the highest post and getting a good stretch on the long scratching pole. Instead of cardboard and sisal, the scratching surfaces are made from carpeting and heavy-duty rope that both looks nicer and will likely last longer. It’s without a doubt a splurge (and actually more expensive than my custom cat tree), but instead of looking like an actual tree, it has a more contemporary style that might work better depending on your space.

What I do have the space and money for is a smaller scratching post, and cat owners know you can never have enough of them. Besides looking like it’d last a long time, this minimalist one has a catnip-infused core that makes it even more attractive to cats than your furniture.

I’d much rather take Lovey to the vet in this nubuck leather tote-style carrier than my current bulky one. It has cutouts for ventilation that also let cats peek out, a washable insert, and a front zipper on one side for easily loading your kitty in and out. The nice thing about the bag is that, if you’re looking at it from the side without the zipper, it just looks like a leather tote with an interesting pattern, so passersby would never realize there’s a cat inside.

The plastic mat I have under Lovey’s food and water bowl is starting to show its age. This easy-to-clean silicone one comes in a bunch of colors, but I’m partial to the “Seaweed Green.” Of course I’d also need the matching bowl and stand.

This aesthetically pleasing update to the ever-popular wand toy replaces the plastic rod with a birchwood one that cats can safely chew on, and the feathers (that inevitable get torn out) with a wool ball and cotton fish that look sturdy. It’s something that would surely get my cat excited to exercise, and also wouldn’t look bad left out on the floor.

This faux-fur bed just looks ridiculously cozy, not to mention kind of elegant — way nicer than your standard, overstuffed brown-polyester model. Come next spring, there will be even more products available when Tuft & Paw launches its own line. Pieces I’m excited about include a streamlined litter box with an integrated shovel and dust bin, and what Cunningham teases as a new take on the cat perch. “The more we’re working in the space, the more we realize how manys opportunities there still are,” he says, adding that designing products in-house will help make the entire inventory “more accessible to everyone.”